Experts who examine possible meteorites find that the great majority are ordinary Earth rocks or industrial waste. These are the ones that fool people most often, and the quickest way to tell each one apart.
Slag
Tell-tale sign: gas bubbles and a glassy look
The waste left over from smelting metal. It is often heavy and may attract a magnet, but it is full of round bubble holes, can look glassy or drippy, and sometimes contains rusty iron blobs. It turns up near railways, old ironworks, farm tracks and anywhere it was spread as hardcore. Meteorites are solid inside and almost never have gas holes.
Magnetite
Tell-tale sign: black streak, no metal flecks
A black iron-oxide mineral that is heavy (about 5.2 g/cm³) and strongly magnetic, so it passes the two tests people try first. Rub it on an unglazed tile and it leaves a black or very dark grey streak. Inside it looks the same all through, with no bright metal specks and no fusion crust.
Hematite
Tell-tale sign: red-brown streak
Another heavy iron oxide (about 5.3 g/cm³), often shiny grey-black or rusty red, sometimes in smooth lumpy shapes. It is usually only weakly magnetic or not at all. The streak test settles it: hematite always leaves a red-brown streak, like dried blood, however dark the rock looks.
Basalt and other lava
Tell-tale sign: normal weight, bubbles or crystals
Dark volcanic rock is the most common rock on Earth's surface. Its density is about 2.8 to 3.0 g/cm³, so it feels normal rather than heavy, and many pieces have small gas holes or visible crystals. Some basalt contains enough magnetite to tug a magnet weakly, which is why it gets mistaken for a stony meteorite.
Iron concretions
Tell-tale sign: rounded, rusty, sandy or layered inside
Hard lumps that grow inside sand, clay or mud when iron minerals cement the grains together. They can be round, knobbly or shaped like bones, with a rusty brown rind. A broken one shows layers, rings or sand grains, never metal flecks. They are common on beaches, in quarries and in eroding cliffs.
Man-made iron
Tell-tale sign: no nickel, machine-like shapes
Old cast iron, bolts, cannonballs, mill parts and lumps of rusted scrap. They are dense and stick to a magnet, but they lack the 5% or more of nickel that almost every meteorite metal contains, and they often show casting seams, holes or flat faces. Only a laboratory can measure nickel reliably.