How can I teach the Tunguska and Chelyabinsk events?
Compare two airbursts a century apart, using maps, eyewitness accounts, energy estimates and damage patterns to discuss evidence and risk.
Tunguska and Chelyabinsk are powerful case studies for science, geography and citizenship.
Tunguska, 1908. On 30 June 1908, an object exploded over a remote forest near the Podkamennaya Tunguska River in Siberia. It flattened an estimated 80 million trees across about 2,000 square kilometres. People 60 kilometres away were knocked off their feet and felt intense heat. Because the area was remote and the times were turbulent, the first scientific expedition, led by Leonid Kulik, did not reach the site until 1927. No crater or large meteorite fragments were found. Most scientists think a stony asteroid or a comet fragment, perhaps 50 to 60 metres across, exploded several kilometres above the ground.
Chelyabinsk, 2013. On 15 February 2013, a meteoroid about 18 to 20 metres across entered the atmosphere over the Russian city of Chelyabinsk and exploded about 30 kilometres up. It was recorded by countless dashcams and security cameras. The shock wave damaged thousands of buildings and injured around 1,500 people, mostly from flying glass. Many meteorite fragments were recovered, including a piece of about 650 kilograms raised from a lake.
Comparisons for pupils. Map both events. Compare sizes, energies, damage areas and the evidence available. Discuss why Chelyabinsk produced meteorites and Tunguska did not.
Safety lesson. Many Chelyabinsk injuries happened because people went to windows to look at the bright flash. Discuss what to do if you see a very bright fireball: move away from windows and wait for the shock wave.
More about for teachers
- How do I differentiate meteorite lessons for different abilities?
- How can I explain why meteorites are cool when they land?
- How can I teach about water on Earth using meteorites?
- How can I use the Apollo Moon samples in lessons?
- How can I explain chondrules to pupils?
- How can I teach the difference between meteoroid, meteor and meteorite?