How can I teach rusting using iron meteorites?

Question

Accepted Answer

Set up a classic rusting investigation with iron nails in different conditions, then explain why iron meteorites rust on Earth and how museums prevent it.

Iron meteorites rust on Earth because their iron reacts with oxygen and water, especially when salt is present. This links directly to a classic rusting investigation.

Investigation. Set up test tubes with iron nails: 1. Air and water. 2. Boiled water with a layer of oil on top, to remove air. 3. Dry air, with a drying agent such as anhydrous calcium chloride and a stopper. 4. Salt water. 5. A nail coated with oil, grease or paint, in air and water. Leave for a week and compare.

Results. Rust forms where both oxygen and water are present, fastest in salt water. Dry or sealed nails stay largely rust-free.

Meteorite connection. Iron meteorites are mostly iron-nickel metal. On Earth's surface, they rust, especially in damp climates and when they have absorbed chloride from soil. In museums, some iron meteorites continue to crack and weep rust years after collection, because of trapped chloride. Curators store them in dry conditions, often with silica gel, and sometimes in low-oxygen enclosures. Some old specimens were coated with varnish or lacquer.

Discussion. Why do meteorites in deserts and Antarctica survive longer than those in Britain? Why might a museum not simply paint its meteorites? Painting would hide scientific features and contaminate samples.

Extension. Pupils investigate whether nickel content affects rusting, using stainless steel or nickel-plated items as comparisons.

Safety. Follow standard procedures for handling chemicals such as calcium chloride, and dispose of rusty water appropriately.

How can I teach rusting using iron meteorites?

More about for teachers